Quote:
|
Originally Posted by unregistered
clearly Pug's intent was to compare commercial kit offerings,
not an assemblage of components from various sources
or again, was he so doing ?
Pug needs to better define his challenge
|
Ok. I've been doing some digging. The kit I originally had in mind has also been submitted to a magazine for a shootout with other commercial offerings which will be published this time next month...
I got this month's issue yesterday and whaddya know? There's a review in there of the Swiftech 22501 Extreme kit with a retail price just 50p more than the MSRP of ours. It also uses a twin 120mm rad.
Assuming the 6002 would be a replacement for the MCW5002, what's wrong with setting these two kits against each other?
([Edit] With your proposed block substitution, of course)
It appears to cover all aspects that would set us on the level playing field I'd hoped for - complete kit, same price point, twin fan rad, fill & bleed sytem (equivalent to our res approach).
Should quantify whether our approach is "adequate" and yours is "performance oriented" quite well.
