Pro/Forums

Pro/Forums (http://forums.procooling.com/vbb/index.php)
-   General Liquid/Water Cooling Discussion (http://forums.procooling.com/vbb/forumdisplay.php?f=9)
-   -   Low cost flow meter? (http://forums.procooling.com/vbb/showthread.php?t=11721)

Marci 06-15-2005 07:11 AM

Definitely love the idea.... currently using the mCubed flowmeters and they themselves cripple flow. An alternative that'd work with the same hardware would be invaluable...

nexxo 06-15-2005 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave
Yes, but it seems adaptable so we can do an RPM to Flow conversion.

I will email them about some kind of license, link or something.

It's simple. The SF800 produces a 100Hz signal per litre per minute flow. So interpreted as an RPM value by the mobo, and by MBM, it produces 6000 RPM per litre flow. In MBM you can divide the RPM value by 6. You then get, effectively, ml per minute flow. You just display this in Samurize using the 1000 decimal dot. Presto.

Rezistor 06-15-2005 10:38 PM

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v1.../25_resize.jpg

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v1.../51_resize.jpg

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v1.../07_resize.jpg

This is a Proteus Industries 200 Series flow meter . The spinning impeller contains magnets at the tips, which generate a current in the coil that is located in the housing of the meter, separated from the chamber. The current, generated in the coil by the Hall effect, is directly proportional to the rotational speed of the impeller, thus being linearly indicative of the flow through the meter. The second half of the flow meter contains all the electronics that interpret the current and convert it to a 0-5VDC analog output. It also contains a relay with an adjustable trip point.

I connected the Red Lion DC voltmeter to read the analog output from the flow meter. Also, this model of the meter can be set to scale the readout, and this is how I calibrated the meter to display 100 under normal circamstances. The buzzer is connected externally and is activated when the relay inside the flow meter senses flow that is below a set point.

The flow meter is able to output analog voltage signal that is proportional (very linearly) to the flow, and I have calibrated the panel meter to show 100, as in 100 percent, under normal conditions. I can adjust the voltage supplied to the pump through a pot, and the meter mirrors the reduced flow quite nicely, bottoming out at 36%, at which point the relay inside the flow meter trips off another relay that is connected to a loud buzzer, giving a nice warning signal.

jaydee 06-15-2005 10:45 PM

[quote=Rezistor]

This is a Proteus Industries 200 Series flow meter
Looks nice, but they want $250+ for it... Not exactly low cost.

Rezistor 06-15-2005 10:49 PM

[quote=jaydee]
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rezistor

This is a Proteus Industries 200 Series flow meter
Looks nice, but they want $250+ for it... Not exactly low cost.

Ebay hooked me up with this one. I do agree wholeheartedly about the MSRP, the only explanation I can come up with that could start to explain the excessive price is the original intent for industrial application, along with the installation, callibration, maintenance, and tech support. But honestly, building the circuit board inside probably won't cost more than $20, and milling out a piece of 1/2" thick plastic should be even cheaper.

jaydee 06-15-2005 10:52 PM

[quote=Rezistor]
Quote:

Originally Posted by jaydee

Ebay hooked me up with this one. I do agree wholeheartedly about the MSRP, the only explanation I can come up with that could start to explain the excessive price is the original intent for industrial application, along with the installation, callibration, maintenance, and tech support. But honestly, building the circuit board inside probably won't cost more than $20, and milling out a piece of 1/2" thick plastic should be even cheaper.

Yeah, it is an interesting idea. I would probably use delrin or even brass for the housing. I like the idea of seeing the flow aswell.

Rezistor 06-15-2005 10:57 PM

[quote=jaydee]
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rezistor
brass for the housing

I've got Proteus 100 Series flow meter with brass housing, and I would not recommend a brass housing for computer use. It weighs 2 pounds! It needs some serious support, you can't just let it hang on the hose, it'll put immense stress on the barb that's attached to that piece of hose.

jaydee 06-15-2005 11:13 PM

[quote=Rezistor]
Quote:

Originally Posted by jaydee

I've got Proteus 100 Series flow meter with brass housing, and I would not recommend a brass housing for computer use. It weighs 2 pounds! It needs some serious support, you can't just let it hang on the hose, it'll put immense stress on the barb that's attached to that piece of hose.

2 pounds of brass shouldn't be needed for this application. :shrug: IMO the meter should be as small as possible to fit in all cases not just monster cases. It should be no larger than 2" x 2" x 1.5" thick and preferably smaller. Shouldn't weigh more than 1/2 pound. Delrin would probably be the thing to use. Anything larger than a MCP350 pump would be to big and take up to much room in mid to small cases. If they want to sell a lot of these then they need to make them fit in as many variety of cases possible. Seeing the flow isn't necessary either but would be nice.

Marci 06-16-2005 06:51 AM

And as for that link to wizd forums... ( http://www.wizdforums.co.uk/showthre...ight=flowmeter )

What he's trying to do has already been done and is commercially available already at low cost... and has been for... er... about 4 years I think (as long as the Innovatek Rev3 waterblock hsa been in existence) - See http://www.webshop-innovatek.de/0000...3e0eac52f.html

They also do this one - http://www.webshop-innovatek.de/0000...3b0dc5e17.html
and this one - http://www.webshop-innovatek.de/0000...3e0e2802b.html

All in the region of 20 euros... ish... and all can be gotten in the US from http://www.highspeedpc.com/

Jag 06-16-2005 07:21 AM

Jaydee,

Don't know if you gave up on the idea of buying a Swissflow flowmeter or not, but Elfa (www.elfa.se), a European distributor sells it.
As for the shipping costs, it's the same story as when i want to buy something from the U.S.
http://www.elfa.se/images/lowres/l2153.jpg

Dave 06-16-2005 07:45 AM

Ok Marci, no problem, I was just trying to help out.

If there is already a solution out there, then not much use in making a mold.

Unless you think using jewel bearings will be much of an improvement?

Since I do not have any of these meters, I do not know if there high quality.
Our expensive lab meter has jeweled bearings, and very un-restrictive flow, and I am basically copying that design using magnets we are already producing.

jaydee 06-16-2005 08:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jag
Jaydee,

Don't know if you gave up on the idea of buying a Swissflow flowmeter or not, but Elfa (www.elfa.se), a European distributor sells it.
As for the shipping costs, it's the same story as when i want to buy something from the U.S.
http://www.elfa.se/images/lowres/l2153.jpg

That's a nice site. I can't buy anything from anywhere but the USA though. I have to have detailed and accurate delivery time on shipping as I travel for work and must be home when it arrives or it will be shipped back as there is no one here to receive it. I only get about a week a month were I know I will be home.

mcmad 06-16-2005 09:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave
Ok Marci, no problem, I was just trying to help out.

If there is already a solution out there, then not much use in making a mold.

Unless you think using jewel bearings will be much of an improvement?

Since I do not have any of these meters, I do not know if there high quality.
Our expensive lab meter has jeweled bearings, and very un-restrictive flow, and I am basically copying that design using magnets we are already producing.


Dont stop mate, those innovatek ones kill flow big time, Ive tried them before & lost 50% of flow because of them..

low loss flowmeter would be a biggie for me & many others Im sure.

Marci 06-16-2005 10:27 AM

Yep, I was referring to the guy on WizD forums' project - basically a waste of time when it's already been done, however the Innovatek ones are 1/4" BSP for 8mm OD Tubing, so imagine the ID if you will ;)

A cheap 1/2" ID suitable alternative is certainly required... and I'd definitely have a load off you Dave...

However, rest of those in the uk, if desparate, head to rswww.com and type "compact flow sensor" into the search box.

Quote:

This lightweight, compact flow sensor is manufactured from Grilamid TR55 and has a PTFE filled nylon rotor on a stainless steel shaft. Although intended as a low cost option for flow rates of 1 to 20l/min. the unit is well specified with a working temperature range of 5 to 50°C and a low pressure drop. Basic construction consists of a one piece sensor body housing a turbine rotor. Flow through the unit causes rotation of the turbine which interupts a photelectric beam within the unit. This signal is then processed and the resultant pulse output, being proportional to flow rate, can be used in batch control or totalising etc.

Body - Grilamid TR55
Rotor - 18% PTFE filled nylon
Shaft - Stainless steel
Shaft retainers - Grilamid TR55
Working pressure (max.) - 10 bar
Pressure drop - Max. 0·1 bar at 15l/min.
Flow range (max.) - 1 to 20l/min.
‘K’ factor - 752 pulses per litre
Accuracy - ±5% << ick
Repeatability - ±1%
Temperature range - 5 to 50°C <<ick possibly depending on application
Weight - 16 grams
Connections - 3/8 BSP
Power supply - 5V d.c.
Photoelectric type - Infra-red
Retails at £41 for one off, £39 for 6 off. Certainly an alternative for those in the UK...

They also do one suitable for -25 deg C thru 125 deg C, pressure drop of 1bar at 1cSt - £78 a piece.

They do a dirt cheap one for 15mm diam tubing, if you can adapt it down it may be suitable... only £20.37. Type "Liquid Flow Sensors -15mm dia Pipe" into their search box.

Basically, rswww.com > Automation > Fluid Management & Control > Flow Transducers (if you want to walk yer way thru the catalog and see all the options)

mcmad 06-16-2005 10:48 AM

looks good marci, cheers for that.

Just ordered one, will hook up to my fanomatic pro & see how I get on (controller allows you to enter the pulses/litre of the flow sensor so should be reasonably accurate)

Marci 06-16-2005 11:07 AM

Aye, have used the fanomatics in the past... let us know how you get on...

Dave 06-16-2005 04:34 PM

Guys at DD seem to want a flow meter, so I will go ahead with a mold.

There is no big developement costs here, I have been doing this on my own, using parts AVT already developed, and C-Systems has 1000's.

I designed for a cheap two side MUD insert, so no one here will mind if I use one, and even if we only sell 100 of them, that will cover on mold cost :)

MadHacker 06-16-2005 04:41 PM

Just out of curiosity? How much will it cost?
How low cost is it

Dave 06-16-2005 05:49 PM

^ For a mold blank insert? about $500.
Plastic molds are cheap, if there simple two peice inserts.

It is when you get into 3 or more peice molds, does it get very expensive.
It is all about design and CNC time, which I am doing for free.

We use MUD systems on all our injection machines
http://www.masterunitdie.com/

MadHacker 06-16-2005 06:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave
^ For a mold blank insert? about $500.
Plastic molds are cheap, if there simple two peice inserts.

It is when you get into 3 or more peice molds, does it get very expensive.
It is all about design and CNC time, which I am doing for free.

We use MUD systems on all our injection machines
http://www.masterunitdie.com/

I ment the final "Low Cost Flow Meter"
how much is low cost...

jaydee 06-16-2005 07:19 PM

If it is around $50 or less and works decent I will buy at least 2.

starbuck3733t 06-16-2005 08:58 PM

I was hoping for the neighborhood of $20 - doesn't need to be uber accurate.

As far as the guy on wizd's project - the boards hes making also work on the paddle sensors that have larger (3/8") barbs. The circuit (which is an optical sensor, not like the innovatek products which are AFAIK mechanical) can be used on any paddle wheel based meter.

jaydee 06-16-2005 09:05 PM

if it is $20 or less I will buy 5.

starbuck3733t 06-16-2005 10:24 PM

Ditto. that's about how many I'd need.... well... 1 for 1/2" and then 4 for 6mm ID.

jaydee 06-16-2005 10:58 PM

If DD is going to b the reseller then there is no way they will be under $40 IMO though. Maybe we can get them directy from Dave for less?

Marci 06-17-2005 04:15 AM

Quote:

not like the innovatek products which are AFAIK mechanical
Read the page I linked you to - Innovatek's aren't mechanical, they're IR, and their "available separately" control board used to convert a flow indicator into a flowmeter can also be added to any paddle wheel.

ToasterIQ2000 06-18-2005 02:41 PM

One nice thing about paddle wheel flowmeters is that they're like a good old fashioned 'visual flow indicator' : walk into a room, take a quick or lazy glance that a-way, and feel reassured. Ones with clear plasic or glass on both sides of the rotor let you mount an LED behind them so you can do this in the dark.

If you can take the face off to remove a stray string of teflon tape or whatnot without having to pull it from the loop, that can be convenient too.

Plastics like nylon that can soak up surficants, antioxidants, anticorrosives, whatnot beyond my chemistry / materials testing are a bummer.

Is there a reliable spec. for the bottom end of pulses / sec. that an hypothetical generic fan header should be expected to sense? ( I have a gems rota-flow installed on one old MB that can't sense as slow as the flowmeter signals; it's a fanles / silent rig that could get by on 0.5 lpm. )

Tangent: I'd write off designing a flowmeter around producing an off the shelf correlation between 4-20 mA pulses / sec and lpm or ml/s or gpm of a particular coolant mix of a particular viscosity with a particular thermal conductivity at a particular temperature and pressure. Like 'low cost flowmeter' on the one hand and the lab kit and skills to establish all that on the other...

I suppose it would be possible to design one that worked in only one flow direction, or was good at trapping bubbles in any but one precise vertical alignment -- that would be sad.

That's what comes to mind this afternoon for someone trying to design / build / sell a low-cost paddle wheel meter for this niche.

Price / performance wise the Swissflow does look interesting, and if it puts out a ball park accurate flow based on a common fan divider, well that is nice indeed.

MadHacker 06-18-2005 09:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jaydee
If DD is going to b the reseller then there is no way they will be under $40 IMO though. Maybe we can get them directy from Dave for less?

I'm hoping that being in Canada that i can get them directly from Dave and save myself the customs charges...

nexxo 06-19-2005 07:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToasterIQ2000
Price / performance wise the Swissflow does look interesting, and if it puts out a ball park accurate flow based on a common fan divider, well that is nice indeed.

It does. It is very accurate, connects straight to a mobo fan header and to get ml/min. you just divide the signal by 6 in MBM. I've been messing about with Samurize a bit more:

http://pic18.picturetrail.com/VOL932.../101207747.jpg
(Temps are a bit high today: 24C ambient room temperature...)

Ideally I'd like a nicely engineered paddle flow meter with a window, LED lighting, accurate IR sensing with a straight conversion of RPM to litres/min flow (or GPM, depending on the flick of a switch or jumper), and integrated temperature sensor. Even better if the thing doubles as an airtrap/reservoir. Even better still if you could bolt it straight onto a pump like the Laing DCC or D5.

We can but dream... but since I'm planning a new project and I know someone with amazing CNC skills, I think I may start designing something myself...

billbartuska 06-28-2005 11:46 PM

Digiflow 8000T
 
I just recieved one ($59+shipping). It looks to be an excellent piece. Hooked it up to an Eheim 1048, resevour and radiator and it read 0.48gpm. It has a totalizer and a timer. It appears to be rather restrictive. It is about 3/8" at the narrowest where the impeller is located.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:07 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
(C) 2005 ProCooling.com
If we in some way offend you, insult you or your people, screw your mom, beat up your dad, or poop on your porch... we're sorry... we were probably really drunk...
Oh and dont steal our content bitches! Don't give us a reason to pee in your open car window this summer...