Pro/Forums - "a little off"

Pro/Forums (http://forums.procooling.com/vbb/index.php)

- General Liquid/Water Cooling Discussion (http://forums.procooling.com/vbb/forumdisplay.php?f=9)

- - "a little off" (http://forums.procooling.com/vbb/showthread.php?t=10050)

Gruntville review of Frost-Byte H2O (pg7)

Quote:

Originally Posted by the Gruntville reviewer

The first thing you will notice when looking at this table is the negative results for the GPU/Case temperature comparison. After much re-testing, theorizing, and just plain trying to figure out how the hell that happened, we have come to the conclusion that the methods used by the Catalyst Drivers and the Albatron BIOS in calculating and reporting temperatures are at fault. We all know that temperatures are calculated by complex formulas and it seems that either, or both, formulas that ATI and Albatron use are a little off.

As for the rest of the results, they are very impressive. The efficiency of the water cooling loop that VoyeurMods has put together in

A "little off"?
I went from raised eyebrows to laughing out loud to feeling I just had to share this with someone.
Apologies if it's inappropriate here (probably belongs in a "nerds' humor" forum) - I promise to avoid "outside" reviews for a while and spare you all from my idea of "funny"... :)

I found it more humorous they think the White Water is from Danger Den...

Idle (CPU/Room)
Load (CPU/Room)

Cape CPU Cooler
17
24.5

NexXxos HP
17
23

Swiftech MCW-5002
19
23

Danger Den WhiteWater
16
21

PolarFLO SF
17
20

Danger Den TDX (Frostbyte Case)
14
19.5

Oh come now Jaydee, Danger Den, DTek - practically the same words! ;)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Butcher

Oh come now Jaydee, Danger Den, DTek - practically the same words! ;)

Yeah I guess the letter D can be confusing and troubling at times. :D One would hope that an official review would have it correct though. :shrug: :D

Oh it's Gruntville. I was wondering how the SF kept getting that margin over the WW...
Why would the temperatures be arrived at by formulae at all? Can anyone explain why they wouldn't just measure them?

On another note, I just noticed that the post count is gone...

Diode readings involve a conversion by the reader AA

Quote:

Originally Posted by AngryAlpaca

On another note, I just noticed that the post count is gone...

Just click the persons profile and the post count is there. :)