View Single Post
Unread 08-23-2004, 08:27 AM   #165
Hotseat
Cooling Neophyte
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Canada
Posts: 62
Default

"Forgive me, I have troubles grasping why, for the sake of a few dollars (maybe $5 or so)"

Not sure where you get the 5$ figure from?

Are you suggesting Polycarbonate in place of Alum?

Thats not a good idea, engineering wise.

Machining Polycarbonate is bad... Mmm'K

You can not machine poly without forming cracks, it's a fact that I will not even start to argue about. So you will need to use straight thread adaptors and a o-ring, which are not cheaply available right now.

If you want to use plastic right, that means a mold, which add's big $$ to your value stream.

Given how complex the pump housing is with inner pipe threads, it would be a 3-5 peice mold costing even us, with our own CNC machines, around 10-20K$ USD.

That means 20$ per 1000 units !!

Now if you only wanted to provide a unit with built in bards at a fixed size of 3/8 then the mold drops to around 5-10K, which is what we use on are indusrtial units. However you loose the wide scale system adaptablity.

Guys, I have been a design engineer for 15 years, and there are always compromises to be made, in fact design=compromise.

We will likely go to a plastic pump housing in the future, but would likely be Delrin not polycarb, and be a cost effective hybrid of injection and post machining, and be adaptable to current units

**You should know, that because of the pump action, most Al housings deal with corrosion fine, since the water action cleans excessive area's. It's different then static blocks.
Hotseat is offline   Reply With Quote