[Ozymand]

pH, just ignore him.. he's a troll on a trip and arguing with him won't gain anybody here other than giving him more attention than he craves. Lock the thread and he'll go away.

I do hope the three months he's spent away he's learned something about physics and testing to help improve that flawed article and maybe in the near future present much more technically sound reviews. Is that too much to ask for reviewers to be competent and knowledgable about the subject matter they're trying to review?

That's all anybody here is asking... get knowledgable and do reviews right, JKME. Otherwise, hey, you're the one leaving yourself open for review when you talk out of your ass and make it sound like you know what you're talking about when you don't have any emperical evidence to support it. Bet it's not any different from a real job... you make the mistakes, aren't you responsible for your actions to correct them? Keep on making those mistakes, aren't you fired?