Personal opinion: As a review (rather than a test) its a hell of a lot better than many - perhaps the performance section is a bit confusing and not particularly relevant, but apart from that, I thought it was pretty balanced, explained things simply, and came to reasonable conclusions.
If we were testing cars here, we wouldn't lambast every reviewer who didn't go through the process of independantly dynoing it and putting it on the skidpad and recording 0-60 times, etc. if they simply discussed their opinion on how it drove without making any statements blatantly out of touch with reality. There is a definate need for tests like the ones here at Procooling, but there is also a need for "soft" reviews - ones that offer more detail when it comes to installation/ease of use and focus less on every 0.01°C. Roscal's tests cover both of these aspects niceley, too bad I have to read them in googlese.
__________________
If not, why not?
|