Pro/Forums - View Single Post - why can retailers not understand engineering integrity ?

Lothar5150 · 10-09-2005, 04:45 PM

I posted the scientific method because it is what Bill employs. What ever findings Bill sites can be independently verified. If you want to be critical of testing methods, as Cathar's statements where, that is fine in fact that is constructive to the process. However, attacking Bill's integrity is out of line.

As to his comment on the single pass radiator performance...As you may or may not know, Bill was working on a white paper on radiator performance for his previous employer. The white paper was completed but never published by the previous employer. Having personally surveyed every major radiator and radiator configuration available, Bill clearly has insight into radiator performance no one else has. Perhaps the reason Bill has not posted data is because those data belong to his previous employer.

Further, don't you think Bill would have looked at various configurations of radiators prior to producing the new Swiftech line of radiators? Certainly, there is no cost difference between in producing single vs. dual pass radiators. Why not separate yourself from the pack further? I can only surmise that there was no applicable performance difference found in testing.

10-09-2005, 04:45 PM	#59
Lothar5150 Cooling Savant Join Date: Jun 2002 Location: Surf City USA Posts: 433	I posted the scientific method because it is what Bill employs. What ever findings Bill sites can be independently verified. If you want to be critical of testing methods, as Cathar's statements where, that is fine in fact that is constructive to the process. However, attacking Bill's integrity is out of line. As to his comment on the single pass radiator performance...As you may or may not know, Bill was working on a white paper on radiator performance for his previous employer. The white paper was completed but never published by the previous employer. Having personally surveyed every major radiator and radiator configuration available, Bill clearly has insight into radiator performance no one else has. Perhaps the reason Bill has not posted data is because those data belong to his previous employer. Further, don't you think Bill would have looked at various configurations of radiators prior to producing the new Swiftech line of radiators? Certainly, there is no cost difference between in producing single vs. dual pass radiators. Why not separate yourself from the pack further? I can only surmise that there was no applicable performance difference found in testing.