Heres my take on it.
Its been so long since he closed up shop you have only a few options:
1. Contact your local Postmaster and file a complaint against chip for mail fraud
2. Contact your Attorney General and file a complaint against chip for fraud
3. Contact the Ohio Attorney General and file a complaint against chip for mail fraud
4. go to your local poice station and ask them what they think you should do in such a case.
There is NOTHING I can do at this point. I would love to see his ass get reamed by an attorney general though