Quote:
Originally posted by pHaestus
Jaydee the guy hasn't even posted a review yet and you have managed to critique and reject it sight unseen? Now who's being objective again? The main reason that there isn't more decent dialogue among testers is the rampant flaming that goes on in this forum with no real reason. There are people that do poor jobs at testing because they don't give a shit and are only looking for page hits/ad money/free goods. There are people who do poor jobs with testing because they are new to it and just learning the ropes. Feel free to trash the first group of people, but please don't attack the second because it would be preferable to have them continue to learn and improve and contribute. I still fall into the second category in fact 
|
I find this to be completely unacceptable actually. I don't give a shit if he or you is still learning or not. If he/you can't do a correct job then it needs not be done at all.
I find this to be complete garbage. It contradicts just about every review ever done on any of these blocks including more respected one's such as JoeC's. This guy needs to relook at what he is sprewing and recheck his methods. Also jumping into a thread as a reviewer and defending a certain block with numbers he doesn't even belive in (he stated it himself) is nothing more than a complete waste of time for everyone. And I cannot figure out why he says his numbers are not solid. Is he not testing each block one at a time? Why are the numbers "ish" instead of set in stone on each block. From what I can see he has not tested any of these blocks ecxept a few minutes at a time.
Quote:
|
At 2250mhz on an XP2400+ at 1.85v, HE120.3 radiator, Eheim 1060 pump, Im getting about 37c with the Cascade and 36c with the RBX. Compared to the Maze4 which runs 39-40c, the AquaJoe at 41c, MCW5002 at 42c, SlitEdge at 42c, ThermoChill at 40c, and whatever else I tested.
|
This speaks for itself. Yes I have already dismissed his review for the reason above. He sounds like an unorganized fool. Why should I NOT dismiss it?
Unregistered: I would LOVE to hear what your definition of "sufficent experience" is!!! This will help many people in deciding if they are capable of testing or not. Myself inculded.